Greetings, fellow Freedom Fighters™ and Defenders of Democracy™!
Today, we bring you another emergency post: today's daily briefing from the Center for American Progress's Progress Report. This issue was jam-packed with so much good information that we wanted to present it by itself and give our Readers a chance to read it thoroughly.
Topics in this issue include
- blockage of the administration's plan to drill in Alaska's wetlands
- Christine Todd Whitman's lies re the safety of NYC after 9/11 coming home to roost
- more proof of the apocryphal "Path to 9/11" pro-Bush, anti-Clinton, fact-free propaganda-fest
- Rep. Curt Weldon's (R-PA) plan to strip Bush and Rumsfeld of war powers
- Bolton's confirmation process dead in the water
- Bush's failure to push legalization of illegal wiretapping through Congress
- and much more!
Keep the faith and keep fighting; together; we WILL win our nation back!
-----
Center for American Progress: the Progress Report
Subject: Progress Report: Taking the 'Docu' Out of 'Docudrama'
GOOD NEWS
"A federal judge issued a preliminary ruling on Thursday that temporarily blocks the U.S. administration's plan to allow oil development in the sensitive wetlands near vast Teshekpuk Lake in Arctic Alaska."
STATE WATCH
OHIO: An initiative to raise the state's minimum wage has qualified for the ballot.
MISSISSIPPI: Lawmakers are being urged to increase regulation of the payday lending industry.
NEW YORK: NYPD's top counterterrorism expert says terrorists still see New York City as a prime target for an attack.
CALIFORNIA: Declining numbers of African American students prompts UCLA to move toward a major shift in the admissions process for November 2007 applicants.
BLOG WATCH
THINK PROGRESS: Conservative author Richard Miniter: "There's zero factual basis" for key scene in "The Path to 9/11."
THE CAUCUS: New York Times launches politics blog.
FIRST DRAFT: U.S. military's top lawyers line up to oppose Bush's new military commissions legislation.
POLITICAL ANIMAL: Musharraf's last stand?
DAILY GRILL
"Former EPA administrator Christine Todd Whitman is blaming the city for not forcing Ground Zero workers to wear respirators."
-- Newsday, 9/8/06
VERSUS
"[Whitman] was quoted in Newsday on Sept. 15, 2001, as saying, 'There is no reason for concern,' referring to asbestos measurements at Ground Zero and elsewhere in lower Manhattan. And on Sept. 16, she said, 'New York is safe.'"
-- Newsday, 9/8/06
ARCHIVES
Progress Report
STUDENTS
Politics with an Attitude: Everyone from Barack Obama to Stephen Colbert talks to Campus Progress. Right-wingers seem scared of us. Find out why here.
by Judd Legum, Faiz Shakir, Nico Pitney
Amanda Terkel and Payson Schwin
September 8, 2006
Taking the 'Docu' Out of 'Docudrama'
Go Beyond The Headlines
Coffee and Donuts Not Included
For news and updates throughout the day, check out our blog at ThinkProgress.org.
Sign up | Contact us | Permalinks/Archive | Mobile | RSS | Print
MEDIA
Taking the 'Docu' Out of 'Docudrama'
Scheduled to air around the five-year anniversary of the September 11 attacks, ABC's docudrama "The Path to 9/11" has elicited a firestorm of criticism for being an inaccurate and deeply-biased account that blames President Clinton for the 9/11 attacks while praising President Bush's response. Written by avowed conservative Cyrus Nowrasteh, the film claims to be based on the bipartisan 9/11 Commission report, despite containing numerous factual inaccuracies that have no basis in the Commission's work. Senate Democratic leaders, led by Harry Reid (D-NV), wrote a letter yesterday to Robert Iger, CEO of the Walt Disney Company (the parent company of ABC), urging him to "cancel this factually inaccurate and deeply misguided program." Clinton lawyer Bruce Lindsey also wrote Iger, explaining, "The content of this drama is factually and incontrovertibly inaccurate and ABC has a duty to fully correct all errors or pull the drama entirely." Feeling the heat and recognizing its errors, ABC "has in recent days made changes to the film" and is claiming "the editing process is not yet complete." As the Families of September 11 have said, the events surrounding 9/11 are far too important to play politics with. Take action now -- join the over 69,000 individuals who have called on ABC to tell the truth about 9/11.
ALL DRAMA, LITTLE DOCUMENTARY: In recent days, the film's writers and consultants have begun distancing themselves from the factual inaccuracies contained in the film. Nowrasteh has said that a key scene falsely in the movie -- which alleges that former National Security Adviser Samuel Berger failed to pull the trigger on a surefire opportunity to kill Osama bin Laden -- was "improvised" by the actors on the set. "Accidents occur, spontaneous reactions of actors performing a role take place," Nowrasteh argued. Former 9/11 Commission Chairman Thomas Kean, who acted as a senior consultant and was credited as co-executive producer of the movie, "admitted...some scenes in the film are fictionalized." Actor Harvey Keitel, who plays FBI special agent John O'Neill in the film, said, "You can't put things together, compress them and then distort reality." ABC and its defenders have evolved their positions on the movie, emphasizing that the miniseries is a "dramatization, not a documentary." But in fact, ABC publicized this film as the official rendering of the 9/11 Commission report. Executive producer Marc Platt and Nowrasteh said earlier that they wanted to "match the just-the-facts tone of the report." ABC producers earlier claimed the film was "based solely and completely on the 9/11 Commission report." For ABC to now suggest that the miniseries was not billed as a documentary is disingenuous. Steve McPherson, president of ABC Entertainment, explained the project in the following way: "When you take on the responsibility of telling the story behind such an important event, it is absolutely critical that you get it right."
CRITICISM COMING FROM ALL DIRECTIONS: While some conservatives have tried to argue that critics of "The Path to 9/11" are simply partisans who are "whining," the truth is that complaints have reigned down from all circles, including from conservatives, former Bush officials, and 9/11 Commission members. Conservative author Richard Miniter, who wrote a book blasting President Clinton's counterterrorism policies, has acknowledged that there is "zero factual basis" for the "idea that someone had bin Laden in his sights in 1998 or any other time and Sandy Berger refused to pull the trigger." Conservative media watchdog Brent Bozell said ABC should "correct" the scenes that "do not have any bearing on reality." Former counterterrorism officials Richard Clarke and Roger Cressey, who worked for Presidents Clinton and Bush, have blasted the movie and said that scenes in the movie are completely made-up. Many former members of the 9/11 Commission have also spoken out against the film. Richard Ben-Veniste said that as members of the Commission were watching a private screening of the film, "we were trying to think how they could have misinterpreted the 9/11 commission s finding the way that they had. Jamie Gorelick told Iger, "I hope that you will correct the record before series airs," and Tim Roemer told CNN yesterday that the Berger scene had no basis in the 9/11 report. Even Kean said he "had pointed out the issue" with the Berger scene to ABC recently, and according to CNN, ABC told Kean "they would go back and take a look at the scene."
SCHOLASTIC CUTS PARTNERSHIP WITH MOVIE: Scholastic Corporation, one of the leading distributors of educational materials for children, announced yesterday that it was ending its partnership with "The Path to 9/11" film. Scholastic and ABC had earlier announced a pact to produce "online study guides" related to the film and to send 100,000 educators a letter from Kean informing them of such materials. As Media Matters documented, the discussion guides were "rife with conservative misinformation" and key omissions which resulted in a distorted account of pre-Iraq war WMD capabilities and misleadingly suggested a tie between Iraq and 9-11. In a press release, Scholastic stated the educational materials "did not meet our high standards for dealing with controversial issues." Scholastic will produce a new classroom discussion guide to that it claims will not aid in "promoting the program" but will still encourage the use of the film as as a "teachable moment." Rep. George Miller (D-CA), the ranking member of the House Education and Workforce Committee, called on teachers across the country not to use "The Path to 9/11" to educate their students about the history of 9/11 because of the film s inaccuracies.
A PRECEDENT FOR CANCELLATION: If the film's inaccuracies cannot be corrected prior to its scheduled airing, ABC should not to run it. There is precedent for such a decision. In Nov. 2003, CBS announced that it would broadcast a mini-series called "The Reagans," which many conservatives argued contained fabricated dialogues about Ronald and Nancy Reagan. The National Review's Ed Morrow wrote at the time, "Attempts to distort our history must be resisted. Historical truth is simply too valuable to be made a plaything for biased filmmakers rewriting it to fit their politics." Similarly, the Review's Seth Leibsohn said, "We should all be ashamed of bad history, though -- of dressing up fiction as fact." Wall Street Journal editorialist James Taranto acknowledged the similarities in the arguments being made against the two movies: "The Clintonites may have a point here. A few years ago, when the shoe was on the other foot, we were happy to see CBS scotch 'The Reagans.'" Daily Variety reports today that, just as the Reagan documentary was pulled from CBS, a similar fate may soon hit "The Path to 9/11." "Sources close to the project say the network, which has been in a media maelstrom over the pic, is mulling the idea of yanking the mini altogether," the Variety writes.
Under the Radar
INTELLIGENCE -- SENATE COMMITTEE RELEASES PORTIONS OF PHASE II IRAQ INTEL REPORT: The Senate Intelligence Committee voted yesterday to release a 400-page report that "covers only two of the five topics outlined under Phase II" of the committee's report on the manipulation of intelligence preceding the Iraq war. "Much of the information -- on the intelligence supplied by the INC and Chalabi and the overestimation of Saddam's WMD threat -- has been documented in numerous studies." The documents will be available on the committee's website later today. The "heart of the report" -- an "analysis comparing the Bush administration's public statements about the threat posed by Saddam Hussein with the evidence senior officials reviewed in private" -- "remains mired in partisan recrimination and will not be released before the November elections." Committee Chairman Pat Roberts (R-KS) promised to continue working on the report, although he has in the past called Phase II a "monumental waste of time." Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-WV) said the released portions would show the "administration pursued a deceptive strategy of using intelligence reporting that the intelligence community had already warned was uncorroborated, unreliable, and in some critical circumstances, fabricated."
AFGHANISTAN -- VIOLENT TALIBAN RESURGENCE WREAKS HAVOC IN SOUTHERN PROVINCES: Nearly five years after the Taliban was overthrown, "the fighting in Afghanistan is the bloodiest since" the beginning of the war. A violent Taliban resurgence has killed more than 1,600 people over the past four months, including many American and NATO soldiers. Just yesterday, "a suicide car bomb struck a convoy of U.S. military vehicles in Kabul on Friday, killing at least seven people," including two American soldiers. This increase in violence has prompted NATO commander Gen. James L. Jones to call for "as many as 2,500 more soldiers and additional aircraft" in an effort to prevent provinces in southern Afghanistan from collapsing. Among the Afghan public, "resentment and disenchantment" are spreading because of the "glacial pace of reconstruction coupled with corrupt and inept local government," leading many to support the Taliban. Basic social infrastructure, such as a police force, judiciary, and civil service, has "[fallen] by the wayside." In addition, because "ordinary Afghans still live without power, water or other amenities," many have resorted to growing one of the nation's top cash crops: opium. Afghanistan's opium harvest is up 60 percent since last year, causing concern in the United Nations that "the bumper crop was helping fuel the deadly Taliban-led insurgency in the south."
IRAQ -- REP. WELDON PROPOSES PLAN TO STRIP BUSH AND RUMSFELD OF WAR POWERS: Rep. Curt Weldon (R-PA), the number-two Republican on the Armed Services Committee, has proposed legislation that would essentially "remove George Bush and Donald Rumsfeld from the military chain of command over Iraq." Weldon "is a strong supporter of the U.S. military mission in Iraq," and once made plans to travel to Iraq and secretly "go digging by the Euphrates for a cache of WMD he believed to be there. The Hill reports, his resolution "would give military commanders -- instead of President Bush or Secretary of Defense Don Rumsfeld -- decision-making authority over when American troops should return home." Weldon is "in the midst of a difficult reelection campaign because of voters generally sour view of the war in Iraq." Sens. Jack Reed (D-RI) and Lindsey Graham (R-SC), two members of the Armed Services Committee, suggested the legislation was unconstitutional. It would subvert civilian leadership of the military, Graham said.
Think Fast
Sources tell the New America Foundation's Steve Clemons that John Bolton's confirmation process "is now dead." "The Senate Foreign Relations Committee is 'highly unlikely' to reconsider Bolton's confirmation again as things now stand."
Yesterday, the Senate unanimously reinstated a special CIA unit dedicated to hunting Osama bin Laden. The CIA received intense criticism after closing the unit in late 2005.
Maryland Comptroller William Donald Schaefer continued to throw personal attacks at his opponent, Janet S. Owens, saying she is "getting fat" and "her husband rules her." He added that she "prissy little miss" who wears "long dresses, looks like Mother Hubbard -- it's sort of like she was a man."
"The Senate passed legislation Thursday night that would create a massive, Google-like searchable database to track federal spending." The bill passed "by a voice vote after both Republican and Democratic senators dropped their objections to it."
Richard Woollam, the former head of pipeline-corrosion at BP Alaska, invoked the Fifth Amendment in testimony before a House subcommittee. The company transferred Woollam to Houston in 2005 "amid concerns that he intimidated potential whistleblowers."
"President Bush's support proved insufficient to push a bill authorizing his warrantless wiretapping program through the Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday." The bill stalled after Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI) "spoke against the bill for about a quarter of the panel's two-hour meeting and offered four amendments."
British Prime Minister Tony Blair, whose reputation has been badly damaged by his support for the U.S. war in Iraq, promised to step down within a year.
The possibility of compromise on comprehensive immigration reform "is essentially dead." House conservatives, "who have campaigned hard against illegal immigration with few legislative accomplishments to show for it," will "try to cobble together a package of border crackdown measures before their recess next month."
And finally: Congress horses around. Rather than deal with "war in Iraq and Afghanistan, terrorism and border problems, high energy prices and health-care costs," the House's first order of business was HR 503, the American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act. "The debate - lasting nearly four hours while horse lover Bo Derek watched from the gallery - quickly degenerated into dueling expressions of equestrian love."